MENU
  • Loading ...
  • Loading ...

Accommodation Hamilton Island

Latest News Accommodation Hamilton Island

Karen Read murder case verdict reached after deadlocked first trial

19 Jun 2025 By foxnews

Karen Read murder case verdict reached after deadlocked first trial

Are you looking for a holiday? Get special deals.

 

Jurors have reached a verdict in Karen Read's retrial in the murder of her Boston police officer boyfriend John O'Keefe, who prosecutors allege she killed in a drunken hit-and-run during a blizzard on Jan. 29, 2022.

Jurors found Read not guilty of second-degree murder, the top charge, but guilty of a lesser offense of operating a vehicle under the influence with a blood-alcohol level of .08% or greater.

Special prosecutor Hank Brennan requested 1 year of probation and that Read be entered into a 24D outpatient program - routine penalty for a first drunken driving offense.

 The trial saw more than 30 days of testimony and four days of deliberation. Read was also found not guilty of drunken driving manslaughter and fleeing the scene of a deadly accident. Her first trial on the same charges ended without a verdict last year when jurors deadlocked.

FINAL DEFENSE WITNESS IN KAREN READ TRIAL PUMPS BRAKES ON LEXUS COLLISION THEORY

Cheers of her supporters, who had been waiting for an update across the street from the courthouse, could be heard inside the courtroom. 

For Read's second trial, the commonwealth appointed a special prosecutor, high-powered defense attorney Hank Brennan, and Read added New York defense attorney Robert Alessi to a team that included Los Angeles' Alan Jackson and Boston's David Yannetti.

Jack Lu, a retired Massachusetts judge and Boston College law professor, called the outcome "a stunning victory for the defense" that he said would also help Read in a civil lawsuit against her from O'Keefe's family.

WATCH 'KAREN READ TRIAL LIVE' ON FOX NATION, HOSTED BY PAUL MAURO

The investigation of Read's case led to investigations into the investigators, leading to an audit into the Canton Police Department and the firing of a state police homicide detective.

"Today's outcome may bring a sense of relief to some and continue to raise questions for others," said John McCourt, chairman of Canton's governing body, the select board. "We encourage members of the community to move forward together, treating one another with respect through civil, constructive dialogue."

Read found O'Keefe around 6 a.m. lying in the snow and unresponsive. She was with two other women - Jennifer McCabe and Kerry Roberts, both of whom testified against her during the trial.

They said Read called them in a panic that morning and said she couldn't find O'Keefe.

McCabe testified that on the morning in question, Read repeated three times, "I hit him."

Paramedic Timothy Nuttall, the first witness to take the stand in the trial, said he overheard Read saying the same thing - three times again.

But the defense argued that a collision never happened.

GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB

The couple and other friends and acquaintances, including McCabe, had been out drinking in downtown Canton before they were invited to an after-party at the home of Brian Albert, who testified in the first trial but not the second.

SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER

O'Keefe was found on Albert's lawn hours later.

Witnesses said they saw Read's car outside but neither she nor O'Keefe went into the gathering. She did not testify in her own defense - but she told reporters outside court that she saw O'Keefe go inside before she drove away.

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

Throughout the trial, Brennan played clips of Read's televised interviews, giving jurors a chance to hear not only her version of events, but other commentary she gave journalists, including how she was spiking her own drinks at the bar before O'Keefe's death and an encounter with O'Keefe's mother afterward.

Prosecutors allege Read hit O'Keefe and drove to his house without him. Read's defense has argued she never hit him, blaming his injuries on a dog attack and an altercation with other men at the party.

Fox News' Lissa Kaplan contributed to this report.

More News

Apple's $250M Siri settlement: Are you owed cash?
Apple's $250M Siri settlement: Are you owed cash?
Facial recognition jails innocent grandmother, attorney says
Facial recognition jails innocent grandmother, attorney says
Archaeologists unearth ancient Roman burials beneath bustling district of coastal tourist destination
Archaeologists unearth ancient Roman burials beneath bustling district of coastal tourist destination
PGA Championship tickets are surprisingly cheap one day ahead of Thursday's opening round
PGA Championship tickets are surprisingly cheap one day ahead of Thursday's opening round
TNA Wrestling star AJ Francis makes bold prediction for upcoming street fight: 'It's going to be crazy'
TNA Wrestling star AJ Francis makes bold prediction for upcoming street fight: 'It's going to be crazy'
Olivia Dunne cozies up with Baywatch model Brooks Nader, Oxford police on alert & Rockies girl Gianna Girardi!
Olivia Dunne cozies up with Baywatch model Brooks Nader, Oxford police on alert & Rockies girl Gianna Girardi!
Joy Reid guest accuses America of 'coddling weak White men' in anti-Trump rant targeting conservatives
Joy Reid guest accuses America of 'coddling weak White men' in anti-Trump rant targeting conservatives
Tim Brando joins Dan Dakich, EVISCERATES Lane Kiffin for his racially charged Vanity Fair comments
Tim Brando joins Dan Dakich, EVISCERATES Lane Kiffin for his racially charged Vanity Fair comments
Six illegal immigrants, including 14-year-old, found dead in shipping container along southern border
Six illegal immigrants, including 14-year-old, found dead in shipping container along southern border
Whoopi Goldberg argues America is 'de-balled' and unserious on the world stage
Whoopi Goldberg argues America is 'de-balled' and unserious on the world stage
Three hospitalized in Napa County as California's fatal wild mushroom outbreak continues to spread
Three hospitalized in Napa County as California's fatal wild mushroom outbreak continues to spread
Jim Furyk says Tiger Woods will have a spot on his 2027 Ryder Cup staff despite DUI arrest
Jim Furyk says Tiger Woods will have a spot on his 2027 Ryder Cup staff despite DUI arrest
Illegal aliens accused in Dallas killing of teen mother's unborn baby charged with capital murder
Illegal aliens accused in Dallas killing of teen mother's unborn baby charged with capital murder
Joe Rogan podcast appearance tied to rise in demand for alternative cancer treatment
Joe Rogan podcast appearance tied to rise in demand for alternative cancer treatment
DHS says two women killed six years apart in Texas should still be alive after illegal immigrant's arrest
DHS says two women killed six years apart in Texas should still be alive after illegal immigrant's arrest
Navy SEAL veteran warns China, Russia are watching US-Iran war to gauge American military strength
Navy SEAL veteran warns China, Russia are watching US-Iran war to gauge American military strength
Christian counselors challenge Wisconsin conversion therapy ban after Supreme Court ruling
Christian counselors challenge Wisconsin conversion therapy ban after Supreme Court ruling
Maple Leafs give head coach Craig Berube the boot after a miserable season, GM change
Maple Leafs give head coach Craig Berube the boot after a miserable season, GM change
Are teams that insist on singing 'Sweet Caroline' during games the worst thing in sports?
Are teams that insist on singing 'Sweet Caroline' during games the worst thing in sports?
Jemele Hill becomes surprising voice of reason in Caitlin Clark-Morgan Wallen
Jemele Hill becomes surprising voice of reason in Caitlin Clark-Morgan Wallen "controversy"
Latest News

copyright © 2026 Accommodation Hamilton Island.   All rights reserved.

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z